Tier list · 909 libraries read here
Which psychological horror games actually get played?
54 psychological horror games owned in at least 30 of the libraries read here, ranked by how many owners got past Steam’s two-hour refund window. Across all of them it’s 37%.
S4 games
A11 games
B16 games
#16DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition48% of 75
#17Mouthwashing49% of 55
#18Chicken Shoot Gold53% of 34
#19Neverending Nightmares53% of 32
#20Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice44% of 156
#21House of Detention49% of 37
#22Knock-knock50% of 30
#23Layers of Fear (2016)42% of 121
#24The Cat Lady47% of 32
#25Pathologic 242% of 73
#26GET EVEN44% of 39
#27I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream41% of 44
#28Buddy Simulator 198440% of 42
#29Pathologic Classic HD39% of 69
#30The Hex39% of 62
#31Lust for Darkness37% of 51
C13 games
#32Detention37% of 35
#33Home36% of 33
#34Call of Cthulhu35% of 65
#35Uriel's Chasm32% of 31
#36Observer32% of 60
#37Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk30% of 37
#38Stories Untold26% of 39
#39Pony Island29% of 147
#40In Sound Mind25% of 52
#41The Suicide of Rachel Foster23% of 43
#42Silent Hill: Homecoming10% of 31
#43FlatOut 3: Chaos & Destruction11% of 36
And 1 more: Lone Survivor: The Director's Cut.
D10 games
#45The Exit 86% of 35
#46Paratopic3% of 32
#47Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk2% of 46
#48Amnesia: The Dark Descent17% of 211
#49Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs15% of 148
#50Unplagued2% of 64
#51Paragnosia4% of 79
#52Overcome Your Fears - Caretaker1% of 69
#53Terrors to Unveil - Day Off1% of 79
#548AM1% of 102
Counted from the Steam libraries read here, by the hours Steam has on each game; free games are left out, since Steam lists one as owned only once it has been played. A game owned in only a few libraries is pulled toward the kind’s 37% as if 60 more owners had played it like the typical one, so a lucky handful can’t top the list. S is the top 8%, A the next 20%, B the next 30%, C the next 25%, D the rest.