Pony Island

Games like Pony Island

Matched on the Steam tags players give them, the closest first.

30 games alike in Horror, Psychological Horror and Puzzle, with Lucifer Within Us, DARQ and Windowkill closest.

Which of these do you already own?

Your Steam profile link or name: the games here that sit in your library unopened are wrapped and lit. Public profiles only. No account needed, and no library is saved.

Pony Island: how long it is, and whether it holds up

How this list is made

A game is here when it shares the strongest of Pony Island's Steam community tags, Steam genres and IGDB themes, each shared tag counting for more the fewer games carry it: two metroidvanias are alike, two action games barely. Games of the same series come first, a similar typical length breaks near-ties, and a game sold twice is shown once. The words under a case are the kinds it shares with Pony Island. Up to 30 games are shown, and the list stops where they grow much less alike.

The sticker on a case is the hours its own page leads with: half of the game's Steam reviewers had played that long or less when they gave their verdict. It is not a time to beat.