Like Nightmare Reaper
30 games, the closest first
CULTIC
Nightmare Reaper, but not a roguelike, and even better loved
Loved · 97%Boomer Shooter · Old School
DOOM + DOOM II
Nightmare Reaper, but a third of the hours, and even better loved
Loved · 97%Boomer Shooter · FPS
Warhammer 40,000: Boltgun
Nightmare Reaper, but gorier, and half the hours
Liked · 89%Boomer Shooter · Retro
WRATH: Aeon of Ruin
Nightmare Reaper, but a third of the hours, and more divisive
Mixed · 72%Boomer Shooter · Retro
Borderlands GOTY Enhanced
Nightmare Reaper, but an action RPG, and darkly funny
Liked · 81%Looter Shooter · Loot
Shadow Warrior Classic Redux
Nightmare Reaper, but with ninjas, and funny
Liked · 89%Boomer Shooter · FPS
STAR WARS: Dark Forces Remaster
Nightmare Reaper, but story-rich, and in space
Liked · 89%Boomer Shooter · FPS
Strife: Veteran Edition
Nightmare Reaper, but not a roguelike, and half the hours
Loved · 90%Boomer Shooter · FPS
Warhammer 40,000: Boltgun 2
Nightmare Reaper, but a quarter of the hours
Loved · 94%Boomer Shooter · FPS
Add another you loved
How this list is made
Each game is measured against each of your picks the way a games-like list measures it: the Steam community tags, Steam genres and IGDB themes they share, each counting for more the fewer games carry it. A game's place is how alike it is to your picks together, as a share of each pick's best match, so one alike to two of them comes before one alike to just one. It must be close to at least one of them, as close as it would have to be on that game's own list.
None of your picks is on the list, nor a second release of one, nor a game of their own series. Up to 30 games are shown. Under each name, the kinds it shares with the pick it is closest to, and how it differs from that pick.