Like American Arcadia
30 games, the closest first
The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
American Arcadia, but pixel art, and darker
Loved · 92%Point & Click · Horror
Detention
American Arcadia, but a psychological horror game, and darker
Loved · 96%Point & Click · Thriller
Beyond: Two Souls
American Arcadia, but an interactive fiction game, and your choices matter
Liked · 88%Cinematic · Thriller
Creepy Tale 2
American Arcadia, but hand-drawn, and with several endings
Liked · 86%Point & Click · Side Scroller
DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition
American Arcadia, but a psychological horror game, and a third of the hours
Loved · 93%Horror · Side Scroller
Beacon Pines
American Arcadia, but an interactive fiction game, and cozy
Loved · 98%Emotional · Visual Novel
Detroit: Become Human
American Arcadia, but your choices matter, and with robots
Loved · 96%Cinematic · Emotional
The Last of Us Part I
American Arcadia, but a third-person shooter, and a survival horror game
Liked · 85%Horror · Thriller
DISTRAINT 2
American Arcadia, but psychological horror, and half the hours
Loved · 95%Point & Click · Side Scroller
A Plague Tale: Requiem
American Arcadia, but a stealth game, and twice the hours
Loved · 91%Cinematic · Emotional
Don't Escape: 4 Days to Survive
American Arcadia, but a survival game, and post-apocalyptic
Loved · 98%Point & Click · Thriller
Minds Beneath Us
American Arcadia, but dystopian, and twice the hours
Loved · 96%Cinematic · Cyberpunk
Don't Escape Trilogy
American Arcadia, but a third of the hours, and even better loved
Loved · 99%Point & Click · Thriller
That's not my Neighbor
American Arcadia, but your choices matter, and half the hours
Liked · 89%Point & Click · Thriller
Dreamfall Chapters
American Arcadia, but three times the hours, and more divisive
Liked · 82%Point & Click · Cyberpunk
The Cat Lady
American Arcadia, but a psychological horror game, and darker
Loved · 94%Point & Click · Horror
Goodnight Universe
American Arcadia, but an interactive fiction game
Loved · 97%Point & Click · Cinematic
The Crown of Leaves
American Arcadia, but hand-drawn, and a mystery
Loved · 96%Point & Click · Visual Novel
Summer of '58
American Arcadia, but a walking sim, and a quarter of the hours
Liked · 89%Thriller · Horror
The Walking Dead
American Arcadia, but with zombies, and episodic
Loved · 97%Point & Click · Emotional
Deep Sleep Trilogy
American Arcadia, but pixel art, and a quarter of the hours
Loved · 97%Point & Click · Horror
Add another you loved
How this list is made
Each game is measured against each of your picks the way a games-like list measures it: the Steam community tags, Steam genres and IGDB themes they share, each counting for more the fewer games carry it. A game's place is how alike it is to your picks together, as a share of each pick's best match, so one alike to two of them comes before one alike to just one. It must be close to at least one of them, as close as it would have to be on that game's own list.
None of your picks is on the list, nor a second release of one, nor a game of their own series. Up to 30 games are shown. Under each name, the kinds it shares with the pick it is closest to, and how it differs from that pick.